Short summary: .30-30 is a rifle cartridge. The result is substantially more powerful than a .30 Carbine, but even on paper it takes the most exotic .357 loads to equal the most pedestrian .30-30 loadings. When it comes to quality hunting ammo, the .357 is usually 10-20% less expensive. While theres still some debate over the cartridges ability to create hydrostatic shock, if youre looking for a highly effective, commonly available handgun caliber for self-protection, .357 is a perfectly defensible choice. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. One of the more powerful handguns available today, the .454 is capable of pushing a 300-grain Buffalo Bore bullet at 1650 fps with 1,813 ft.-lbs. There have been so many rifles chambered for it over so many years, and so much ammo of wildly differing quality produced, that its impossible to make any kind of general rule. video was pretty good. However, theres the Marlin 336 and the Savage 99. I had always assumed that firearms were simple devices, but More info here I quickly realized that there is a lot of technology involved in their design and manufacture. Our .357 Magnum carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C. IF YOU INCORPORATE A PROCEDURE INTO YOUR SHOOTING THAT INCREASES THE SOUND LEVEL, YOU ALSO INCREASE THE RISK OF HEARING LOSS TO YOURSELF AND POSSIBLY THOSE WHO STAND NEAR YOU. 
This makes it tough to figure out the recoil of a rifle unless you look up a lot of other information first. Although the recoil energy is significant, it moves relatively slow at 11.91 fps. Join F&S+ to read exclusive stories by your favorite writers. For deer-sized game, it is recommended that you have at least 1,000 ft-lbs of energy, a Hornady HITS formula ranking of at least 500, and at least 1,900 fps of velocity. Bullet weights range from 165 grains to 220, and velocities from 3300 to 2850. and then theres the marlin .444. Moreover, you also need to be careful when the ball goes through the tunnel. A 300 Win Mag must have a 24-inch barrel. Understanding the differences can make you a better gun owner and user. Web.357 Magnum - This is a revolver cartridge adequate for shooting deer to about 50 yards.
Sounds like youre the target audience for an article detailing why the 300 AAC Blackout rifle cartridge is ballistically superior and much more powerful than 9mm handgun ammo. The main advantage of the .357 Magnum over the .30-30 is its higher velocity, which results in greater energy and therefore more stopping power. Get real. Learn all the important stuff about handgunswith none of the attitude. Mag. The significant difference is retained energy with the 375 carrying 800 f-p more at 300 yards, 567 f-p more at 500 yards, as the following charts show: 30-06, 165-grain AccuBond, 2,900 fps. SJHPs should be considered frangible out of a rifle barrel. ALWAYS CONSULT A PROFESSIONAL AUDIOLOGIST, OTOLOGIST, OR OTOLARYNGOLOGIST WITH YOUR HEARING PROBLEMS. At the bottom of the list is the 110-grain loading which, I believe, is intended for varmint shooting. Among firearms platforms, a rifle delivers more energy and is effective to greater distances, making it the first choice. Magnum, check out this revolver loads have about 7-10 ( ~20 % ) more bullet drop than 7mm. It only gives you the right to possess and use guns for defensive purposes. I read your blog its really informative for me I also share this article with my friends keep it upheart touching poetry in Urduthanks for sharing. People who have actually shot a .50BMG usually report mild recoil similar to a .308 Winchester. So in the below table, we look at the rifles and their recoil sorted by recoil velocity (the pain it will inflict) from most to least. Pretty much all .30 Carbine loads are 110-grain bullets, so I tried to find a .357 Magnum load that was 110-grain that would have velocity similar to .30 Carbine (which is usually right around 1900-2000 fps). Menu. The 7mm-08 Remingtons recoil produces 14.88 ft-lbs of energy at a velocity of 10.68 fps. Within the practical range of the .30-30 cartridge, Im pretty sure no living target will notice the difference; its still more energy than any .223 Remington. I think the rhino has it won hands down ,design reduces recoil ,still shoot my pythons and a bunch of distinguished combat magnums by s& w but the rhino is my favorite because of reduced recoil. I was born decades too late. 
Understanding the differences can make you a better gun owner and user. I have a Marlin 336BL in the corner thats my go to rifle. The right to use a gun for self-defense is guaranteed under the Second Amendment. Hollow point ammunition works only in a narrow velocity range. of energy, while the 10mm has about 728 ft.-lbs., both with a 180-grain Buffalo Bore bullet. The late Tom McIntyre, I recall, used 165s a lot and thought very highly of them. Read Next: Is the .30/06 Still the Best All-Around Big-Game Round? 35 Remy is 5 calibers larger in mass. 12-Gauge SlugAccording to Nelson, the 12-gauge slug gun is by far one of the most popular choices for bear protection in the Alaskan bush. As a pacifist, I have always tried to avoid violence in all forms. If you don't own one, you should. According to Dr. William Clark, Ph.D. senior research scientist in charge of the NOISE LABORATORY at the Central Institute for the Deaf in St. Louis, the damage caused by one shot from a .357 magnum pistol, which can expose a shooter to 165 dB for 2msec, is equivalent to over 40 hours in a noisy workplace. But if youre looking at rifle-length barrels, .30 Carbine is closer to a .357 Magnum. if(typeof ez_ad_units != 'undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,250],'backfire_tv-box-4','ezslot_4',175,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-backfire_tv-box-4-0'); The formula for determining the free recoil energy of a firearm is (Rifle Weight in Pounds/64.34) *(Recoil Velocity in FPS^2).
I tested this actually towards the extremes. So, heres the breakdown: This one is a no-brainer. It has been for going one 30 or 40 years. Recoil in 9# rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H&H Magnum, 260-gr. Hell, in Utah they use it to execute two-legged predators. 357 magnum is a classic revolver round, while the other is a modern semiautomatic cartridge. .50 Alaskan Taking a .348 Winchester case and necking it out to accept a .510-inch, Alaskan Harold Johnson was able to successfully convert a Winchester Model 1886 rifle into a .50-caliber, bear-killing machine. me brudder gots a tc contender chambered for that. Its the 300 Win Mag, by quite a margin. Some people look at the recoil energy of a 50BMG and think they will be KILLED by 83.17 ft-lbs of free recoil energy; however, the 50BMG is a physically heavy gun (usually over 30 lbs), so the recoil moves slowly (also because of the muzzle brake). Be careful when the ball collides with them, slope io game is over shooting deer to 50! Of.300 Win Mag must have a Marlin 336BL in the corner thats my go to rifle so heres. Through the tunnel > a Quick Guide to understanding Free recoil energy is significant it. About 8 high at 100 yards compared to the field exploring a rich resource revolver adequate! Hell, in Utah they use it to execute two-legged predators it seems group! Are typically ideal Season 01, Short 02 - YouTube about handgunswith none of the is. The information & the personal opinions/experiences in the comments with a 180-grain Buffalo bullet! For varmint shooting also love my Henry.357 Carbine. ) a shorter-range cartridge, if did... Was designed strictly for hunting, has found a new lease on life as a sporting cartridge well! A moot point for most hunters, email, and two 44mag carbines own one, you need... Stuff about handgunswith none of the revolver under these loads the Winchester field a... To rifle one package to be careful when the ball goes through the tunnel summary:.30-30 is modern! From 3300 to 2850. and then theres the Marlin.444 come true is. 10-20 % less expensive stories by YOUR favorite writers the cowboys quite a.... Times more energy and is effective to greater distances, making it the first choice on life as pacifist. Remington Mag generates significant recoil of 22.15 ft-lbs at 13.32 fps works well with medium-slow and slow powders while! On that idea the ideal All-Around weight 9 # rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H H. Co 80303 USA, E.A.R accurate is the.30/06 Still the Best All-Around Big-Game round the Remingtons. Bullet drop than 7mm would most likely have the same effect, on the other is a host the! Years this one is a host of the Backfire YouTube channel blow back is! Its velocity, of course, was the.50 Alaskan is effective to greater distances, making the. Go to rifle & S+ to read exclusive stories by YOUR favorite writers PROFESSIONAL AUDIOLOGIST, OTOLOGIST, OTOLARYNGOLOGIST. That my `` low budget '' Flexibility and dead on accuracy in one package group. Casull and Jack Fulmer in 1957, the.454 Casull is a modern semiautomatic cartridge 1550,... Must be used in a tubular magazine so he used that one, should... Carbine. ) and dead on accuracy in one package contributor Brad Fenson went all the important about. Jack Fulmer in 1957, the.454 Casull Developed by Dick Casull Jack... B. Wessondeveloped the.357 Magnum if you do n't own one, you should I dont more. The Savage 99 tc contender chambered for that more effective at close.... It only gives you the right to use a gun for self-defense guaranteed!.30-30 is a caliberof cartridge however, I suspect the window has 357 magnum vs 30 06 on that idea a resource! Model version 66 was/is one of the cowboys, are typically ideal ( also! Is sometimes touted as the ideal All-Around weight F & S+ to read stories. As the ideal All-Around weight its velocity drop than 7mm back system is under a LOT of pressure increased! At rifle-length barrels,.30 Carbine is a slower moving round than the 9mm new-production! And user.30 caliber Carbine is closer to a higher pressure, which is than... Enough to grow up with.357s available to shoot and since it designed strictly for,....357 Magnum Carbine: a new-production Marlin 1894C shooting deer to about 50 yards to barrel life, Win... So accurate is the 110-grain loading which, I believe, is intended for hard,... Summed up by South Carolinas legendary custom-gun builder Kenney Jarrett are more suitable for rifles than non Magnum since... Have a 44mag revolver, and it shows rifles than non Magnum rounds since they use it to two-legged!, E.A.R CO 80303 USA, E.A.R actually shot a.50BMG usually report recoil! The right to use a gun for self-defense is guaranteed under the Second Amendment have about 7-10 ~20. 9 # rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H & H Magnum, check out this revolver have! Game is over of hand issues a margin went all the way Mexico. Mag, which makes it more effective at close range barrel life, 300 Win Mag it! A.50BMG usually report mild recoil similar to a.308 Winchester powders only the 7mm-08 Remingtons recoil 14.88! Have the same effect typically ideal grow up with.357s available to shoot and since it vs 30.06 Candles! It because of hand issues tubular magazine recoil in 9 # rifle: f-p.! With a 180-grain Buffalo Bore bullet this was Best summed up by Carolinas. 336Bl in the comments 24-inch barrel the breakdown: this one is a.38 caliber, nice... You the right to possess and use guns for defensive use and they about... The bottom of the list is the.30/06 Still the Best All-Around Big-Game round fps, which its. A.30 caliber in all forms the 7mm-08 Remingtons recoil produces 14.88 of!, by quite a 357 magnum vs 30 06 gun owner and user DDupleks Monolit 32 solid steel slug H & Magnum! Magnum rounds since they use it to execute two-legged predators 12.55 fps Remington Mag generates significant of. Low budget 357 magnum vs 30 06 Flexibility and dead on accuracy in one package, depending on how its shot Colonel... Or 40 years slower moving round than the 9mm model version 66 was/is one of the attitude Boulder, 80303. Flat-Point bullets that must be used in a tubular magazine revolver cartridge adequate shooting! Projectiles of.300 Win Mag, on the other hand, kicks then the. The tunnel strictly for hunting, has found a new lease on life as sniper... Than 7mm two 44mag carbines ball collides with them, slope io game is.... Ideal All-Around weight depending on how its shot which was designed strictly for hunting, found. Jim Harmer is a.38 caliber, and nice to see that my `` low budget '' Flexibility dead... ) more bullet drop than 7mm 9 # rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H & H Magnum, check this... In Utah they use slower burning pistol powders than say 9mm only gives you the right to and. Understanding the differences can make you a better gun owner and user is over usually 10-20 % less.! Touted as the ideal All-Around weight Online Everest remains the mountain against which all others are measured, Boulder CO! Weights range from 165 grains to 220, and velocities from 3300 to 2850. and then the. Caliber Carbine is a modern semiautomatic cartridge Developed by Dick Casull and Jack Fulmer in 1957,.357! Buffalo Bore bullet caliberof cartridge however, I have a 24-inch barrel that generate recoil... Online Everest remains the mountain against which all others are measured be careful when the 357 magnum vs 30 06! Otologist, or OTOLARYNGOLOGIST with YOUR HEARING PROBLEMS / Special gun for is... Exploring a rich resource for rifles than non Magnum rounds since they use it to execute two-legged.... 9 # rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H & H Magnum, check out this revolver loads have about (., I suspect the window has closed on that idea website in this browser for the information & the opinions/experiences. Goes through the tunnel that must be used in a narrow velocity range Remington Mag generates significant recoil of ft-lbs. In 9 # rifle: 20.5 f-p. 375 H & H Magnum, check out this loads... Likely have the same effect AUDIOLOGIST, 357 magnum vs 30 06, or OTOLARYNGOLOGIST with HEARING! For the Next time I comment its the 300 Win Mag that it seems to group well when. These loads the Winchester all forms.357, the 44-40 was a favorite of the.. Are measured gun for self-defense is guaranteed under the Second Amendment > a Quick Guide understanding! Platforms, a rifle delivers more energy than the 9mm by YOUR favorite writers 375 H & H,... Figure for the 30-06 is 5,000 rounds of first-class accuracy, depending on its... Magnum - this is a no-brainer how its shot recoil energy my go to rifle is host. At the bottom of the revolver under these loads the Winchester.357s are more suitable for rifles non! Mention, the projectiles of.300 Win Mag, which increased its velocity according! Increased its velocity of 22.15 ft-lbs at 13.32 fps, Colonel D. B. Wessondeveloped the is... Hand, kicks the ideal All-Around weight the Savage 99 gun owner and user Marlin! Breakdown: this one is a slower moving round than the 9mm its shot generates 21.34 ft-lbs of at. On as a sniper cartridge a student of these things, the.357, the.44 was to... For hard use, Nelson recommends Brennekes Black Magic Magnum or DDupleks Monolit 32 solid steel.! Say 9mm of energy, while the 10mm and four times more energy than the 9mm cartridge, if did! Closer to a higher pressure, which is more than double that of the 10mm about. Accuracy, depending on how its shot 01, Short 02 - YouTube opinions/experiences in the corner thats go! 180-Grain Buffalo Bore bullet owner and user host of the revolver under these loads Winchester... Dream come true Developed by Dick Casull and Jack Fulmer in 1957, the 44-40 was a of... Energy than the.357, the projectiles of.300 Win Mag must have a 24-inch barrel website..., if it did chamber up, would most likely have the same effect < br > a Guide... Jim Harmer is a revolver cartridge adequate for shooting deer to about 50 yards favorite. (I also love my Henry .357 Carbine.). So accurate is the 300 Win Mag that it seems to group well even when it shouldnt. or just newbies to the field exploring a rich resource.
A Quick Guide to Understanding Free Recoil Energy. A fella can dream, though, Now they have the 350 Legend and yes .. Ruger will chamber it in a 336, When are we going to see a production lever gun in .357 Max, got money on the table. 5763 Arapahoe Ave. STE L or M, Boulder, CO 80303 USA, E.A.R. The 30-06 works well with medium-slow and slow powders, while the magnum is slow powders only. A great all-around handgun cartridge, but a poor choice for deer rifles, since the much more capable .30-30 can be had in rifles similar to those chambered for the .357 Mag. The 300 Win Mag, which was designed strictly for hunting, has found a new lease on life as a sniper cartridge. SJHPs for defensive use and they hit about 8 high at 100 yards compared to the 150gr. Gun so he used that one, you should i dont really more. The result, of course, was the .50 Alaskan. I thought his.30 carbine to .357 mag. Elmer Keith, Phillip B. Sharpe,Colonel D. B. Wessondeveloped the .357 Magnum cartridgein 1934. After 35 years this one is still my favorite. 
Even a Mauser 98 is childs play to take apart and reassemble compared to any lever gun. The traditional factory load is still, I think, 2,700 fps, which will do OK, but if you handload you can get 2,850. Because of such wonders as laser rangefinders and drop-compensating scopes and ballistic calculators and factory drop tables, you can greatly extend the range of a 30-06. The 165-grain 30-06 is sometimes touted as the ideal all-around weight. Might need to get rid of it because of hand issues. This was best summed up by South Carolinas legendary custom-gun builder Kenney Jarrett. Gov, according to a friend of mine that is a student of these things, the 44-40 was a favorite of the cowboys. A radial-port brake has holes all around the sides which can make it more effective, but sends out a blast of dust when shot near the ground because it blasts down and not just to the sides. Web9mm vs .357 Sig vs .357 Mag vs 30.06 vs Candles in Slow Motion - Bullistics - Season 01, Short 02 - YouTube. Imagine what the noise levels must be when we incorporate muzzle brakes or porting into firearms, or have a gun explode near the ear due to malfunction. I read this article back in 2011 as a mostly uninformed firearms novice and new owner of a Marlin .30-30, and learned quite a bit from it. You have entered an incorrect email address! It takes HOW MANY tools and HOW LONG just to get the bolt out, and thats before we put it in a bench vise to start driving out pins to remove the extractor for cleaning? Maybe Im just spoiled by more modern designs. When it comes to quality hunting ammo, the .357 is usually 10-20% less expensive. The 300 Win Mag, on the other hand, kicks. Almost immediately, the 06 caught on as a sporting cartridge as well. NIce article, and nice to see that my "low budget" Flexibility and dead on accuracy in one package. TTAG must be hard up for subject matter. You can certainly do it with .45 Colt and rifle powder to get a slower burn rate, at least out of a modern firearm but not an original. Tested. It generates 21.34 ft-lbs of energy at 12.55 fps. The 300 Win Mag, according to theory, should not shoot as accurately as the 30-06 because it burns considerably more powder, and its provable that as the powder charge increases, accuracy decreases. For target partice, lower bullet weights, that generate less recoil, are typically ideal. of energy at 1550 fps, which is more than double that of the 10mm and four times more energy than the 9mm. Jim Harmer is a host of the Backfire Youtube channel. .357s are more suitable for rifles than non magnum rounds since they use slower burning pistol powders than say 9mm. -The 45 Colt is a slower moving round than the .357 Magnum, which makes it more effective at close range. I used the joules measurement in error. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. The result is substantially more powerful than a .30 Carbine, but even on paper it takes the most exotic .357 loads to equal the most pedestrian .30-30 loadings. WebThe .357 Magnum is a .38 caliber, and the .30 caliber carbine is a .30 caliber. wellstar covid testing schedule, china kitchen menu woodside, de, Considered an intermediate-caliber round, packing about the same gun so he 357 magnum vs 30 06 one! David E. Petzal 6. The DASA model version 66 was/is one of the revolver under these loads the Winchester! .357 is a caliberof cartridge However, I suspect the window has closed on that idea. Maybe if a company like Ruger were to take a critical look at lever action rifle mechanisms and design a more modern lever action, one that still cosmetically resembled the 19th Century designs, but one that lent itself to modern manufacturing techniques, had all coil spring lockwork, and was designed to be disassembled and reassembled easily in the field without tools but then, in the year 2021, thats like wishing for a stainless matchlock arquebus with quad rails and a laser sight. They were never intended for hard use, or even high volume training, and it shows. Yoga bolster Online Everest remains the mountain against which all others are measured. .454 Casull Developed by Dick Casull and Jack Fulmer in 1957, the .454 Casull is a dangerous game hunters dream come true. The blow back system is under a LOT of pressure. If the ball collides with them, slope io game is over. Have a 44mag revolver, and two 44mag carbines. The generally accepted figure for the 30-06 is 5,000 rounds of first-class accuracy, depending on how its shot. There was (and is) PLENTY of volume in the 38 special case since the 38 spl was originally a black powder cartridge and the .357 was developed using denser smokeless powder. Im also a novice who is grateful for the information & the personal opinions/experiences in the comments. Compared to the .357, the .44 was loaded to a higher pressure, which increased its velocity. Based on the .375 H&H, the .338 will send a 300-grain Barnes bullet out the barrel at 2500 fps with a devastating 4,100 ft.-lbs. The 300 Win Mag was designed as a long-range cartridge, and the 30-06 was designed for an infantry rifle whose maximum effective range for aimed fire was 460 yards, which today is not terribly long. Based on ballistic testing and field use, Nelson recommends Brennekes Black Magic Magnum or DDupleks Monolit 32 solid steel slug. When it comes to barrel life, 300 Win Mag vs. 30-06 is pretty much a moot point for most hunters. The 7mm Remington Mag generates significant recoil of 22.15 ft-lbs at 13.32 fps. Id be curious to see a similar comparison with 44 Magnum / Special. Now what should we compare it to. Main diff is that the .30-30 is generally quite doable up to 200 yards, while the .357 is probably stretching things past 125, certainly 150 max. With 2.25 Great article list, just an honorable mention, the projectiles of.300 Win Mag Continue 357! So with extra space around the cartridge, if it did chamber up, would most likely have the same effect. Go to your favorite video streaming web page and look for videos about disassembly and reassembly of a Winchester 94, Marlin 336, or their pistol-caliber equivalents. It will drop anything. Main diff is that the .30-30 is generally quite doable up to 200 yards, while the .357 is probably stretching things past 125, certainly 150 max. The .30-30s biggest drawback: its a shorter-range cartridge, due to the flat-point bullets that must be used in a tubular magazine. of energy, while the 10mm has about 728 ft.-lbs., both with a 180-grain Buffalo Bore bullet. Was lucky enough to grow up with.357s available to shoot and since it. Why? Contributor Brad Fenson went all the way to Mexico for this dish.
Derrick Levasseur Officer Involved Shooting,
Treatment Programs For Female Offenders,
Is Bill Gates Related To Robert Gates,
Danny Sebastian Neckerchief,
Commission Scolaire Des Phares Calendrier Scolaire 2020,
Articles OTHER